Was Einstein wrong?

Space station research may find out

Bluhm, Kostelecky, Lane, Russel PRL 2002

Einstein

The theory, introduced in 1905, holds that if an observer moves at a uniform speed, no matter how fast or in what direction, the laws of physics and the speed of light are always the same. For example, if one stands still and drops a coin, it will fall straight down. If one drops a coin inside a car while driving down the freeway at a steady speed, it will also fall straight down. However, recent theories attempting to combine gravity and particle physics suggest that relativity might not always apply. Changes in space and time may occur that could not be measured easily on Earth.

"The International Space Station will have ultra-sensitive clocks on board, and it is a good place to test the theory," said Alan Kostelecky, professor of physics at IU Bloomington. "By comparing extremely precise clocks that can operate under zero gravity, minuscule changes in the ticking rate might be found as the spacecraft moves around Earth." This would violate Einstein's theory, which says there should be no change if different clocks in the same gravity environment are compared.

"Finding such changes would cause an upheaval in the science community and revolutionize our thinking about the fundamental structure of space and time," Kostelecky said. "It would lead to insight about how our universe formed and how nature operates."

Measurements in space have several advantages over ones on Earth because the Earth's rotation axis and its rotation rate are fixed. In space, the orbital axis of a satellite and its rotation rate can change, and higher speeds are possible. Measurements in space would therefore be more sensitive to minute changes that would violate Einstein's Theory of Relativity.

Kostelecky and his colleagues, Robert Bluhm of Colby College, Waterville, Maine; Charles Lane of Berry College, Mount Berry, Ga; and Neil Russell of Northern Michigan University, Marquette, propose using specific types of clocks on the space station. For example, one type would use a maser, a cousin of the laser. Instead of emitting light, like a laser, the maser emits microwave energy at a specific frequency, which produces a very specific ticking.

Other types of clocks already planned for flight on the International Space Station could be used as well. Upcoming missions include the Primary Atomic Reference Clock in Space, the Rubidium Atomic Clock Experiment and the Superconducting Microwave Oscillator. All three are part of NASA's Fundamental Physics Program. In addition, the Atomic Clock Ensemble in Space will be flown on the International Space Station by the European Space Agency. Kostelecky said clock experiments in space may yield other intriguing results. For example, they might provide evidence for string theory. Traditionally, scientists have believed that the smallest units in the universe are particles. However, advocates of string theory believe the smallest units are elongated, like tiny pieces of string. In some string theories, empty space has an intrinsic direction. This could cause the clocks on the space station to tick at changing rates, depending on their orientation.

In addition to the International Space Station, other future missions may also test the Theory of Relativity. The proposed NASA SpaceTime mission would fly three clocks beyond Jupiter and then drop the spacecraft rapidly toward the sun, like an extreme version of an amusement park freefall ride. The high speed of this mission would make possible new kinds of sensitive tests.

The paper may be found in the Physical Review Letters

Animation of the proposed experiments on the space station is available at:
http://physics.indiana.edu/~kostelec/mov.html